is donnie a virgin when he dies

[gretchen]

while yes, the majority of DD IS open to interpretation, there are some basic facts and truths to it.

i feel that this is one of them.

just like how gretchen and frank are not dead when donnie dies. it's the same concept. regardless of whether it happened or not, everything is reversed.

[Phil]

Thank you gretchen, summed up what i was trying to say alot clearer than i ever could.

[greedy]

you all know i ove a good discussion that is why i started this thread (yes i am the same greedy) but we have two conclusive piece that say he was a virgin the commentary about them not having sex and the fact that all ALL physical actions were null and void when donnie traveled back in time and unless some one finds new evidence to contradict this we should concentrate on more important things

[abelfrye]

he DOES say with the psychiatrist that that's like all he thinks about . and then he unzips his pants and the lady claps twice really fast.

[greedy]

please read the whole post and u will see that the frame of referance is the party when the camera pans away that has been the topic of discussion but it has been closed until a good rebutle can be formed

[gretchen]

abelfrye said:

he DOES say with the psychiatrist that that's like all he thinks about . and then he unzips his pants and the lady claps twice really fast.

wow. that really changed my mind.

does NO ONE READ?

YES, he DIED a VIRGIN.

*LOCKED*

[greedy]

i don't think they do better be nice everyone before u feel the wrath of a GOD lol

[Madridarko]

greedy said:

i don't think they do better be nice everyone before u feel the wrath of a GOD lol

I don't get ur comment, but last thing I remember (please correct me if I am misunderstanding something) is that the whole hand/zipper scene was before the party, where if donnie ever had sex with gretch, we must suppose it was the same night of the party, so up to that point in the party we are to suppose he was a virgin.

[Omnipotent]

Omnipotent said:

Doesn't Dr. Thurman ask him if he's ever had sex before and he acts all timid subliminally implying that he hasn't? I can't be bothered to go put it on but I recall that being in the Director's Cut.

I ended this thread on the first page why is it 6 pages.

[greedy]

because omni people can't accepte hard facts for one and two we didn't have hard facts till page 5 so u can't have ended it on page one however your conclusion on page one "didn't reread it sorry assuming u said he was a virgin" was corretc

[Omnipotent]

greedy said:

because omni people can't accepte hard facts for one and two we didn't have hard facts till page 5 so u can't have ended it on page one however your conclusion on page one "didn't reread it sorry assuming u said he was a virgin" was corretc

I had the hard facts I chose not to type them in this forum........honest

[greedy]

only because of your rank and good reputation i will believe you it's really kinda oblvious when u think about it

[DarkoFan86]

First of all I think that people need to learn to skip over a post if they think it should be "dead", and if they choose to read it not to bitch about it.

Because I think this is along the same lines I will continue the conversation.... When Donnie is in his bed at the end of the movie does he know that he has traveled back in time? If he does and has knowledge of the events that took place then he is NOT a virgin. He had sex and no one can take that away. It would be like saying he never wrote a letter to Roberta Sparrow, he did do this and there is evidence of him doing so.

[Phil]

[greedy]

darko fan the evindence has been reviewed and debated please read the whole post and u will see that